Analysis & comparisons · FormulaMaps · sourced and dated
Home · Compare
Comparisons

Compare us with anyone. With sources, and with dates.

Choosing formulation software is an expensive decision to undo: you put in your recipes, your ingredients and your costs, and then you stay. So here is what we would have wanted to find before paying for anything — the comparison against every tool on the market, including the parts where we don't win.

What we promise on these pages: no figure about a competitor comes from our imagination. It all comes from their official site, with the date we checked it. If a price isn't public we write "not published" — not a convenient estimate. And every comparison has a section saying when the other tool is the better choice.
Sources last verified: 16 September 2026 · corrections: hola@formulamaps.com
FMThe FormulaMaps desk · the Llinares family, ice cream makers since 1947Published and verified: 17 September 2026

Ice cream formulation

The balancing tools you'll actually run into searching in English.

Carpigiani · Balancing App
The app from the most respected gelato school in the world: 70,000 students, 21 campuses in 20 countries. €300 a year, €366 including VAT.
See comparison →
inteliGelato / myGelato.eu
The rival we take most seriously: PAC, POD, EU labelling, waste in the costing. $399/year capped at 100 recipes, one single user.
See comparison →
Ice Cream Calculator
Completely free, no ads, and it calculates PAC, POD and freezing curves. Now a web app too, not just Windows.
See comparison →
Overview · ice cream software
What to check before choosing any balancing tool: the PAC scale, the catalogue, the freezing curve and the real cost.
See the guide →

Dough and pizza

The highest-volume searches in this whole space — and an honest look at where they beat us.

Pandough
598 flours from 157 manufacturers, with W strength and protein. On dough they are better than us, and we say so plainly.
See comparison →
PizzApp+
The veteran dough calculator, with a genuinely mature yeast engine by temperature and time. Free on iOS and Android.
See comparison →
Ooni dough calculator
Free, beautifully made, Neapolitan through Detroit. Excellent for pizza; the difference is who each tool is built for.
See comparison →
Stadler Made
Six pizza styles in a web calculator and genuinely good teaching content — the same philosophy of publishing the science that we follow.
See comparison →

Pastry and bakery

Costing, the baker's percentage and what happens when one tool has to cover several crafts.

Baker's percentage
How it works, why it goes over 100 %, and what it can't tell you on its own.
Read the guide →
Pastry recipe costing
Working out what a piece really costs you, with your own delivery-note prices.
Read the guide →

And the competitor almost nobody names

The tool this entire market really competes with isn't a program: it's a spreadsheet.

The Excel sheet
What your spreadsheet does well, where it stops (PAC isn't "one more column") and when the switch is worth it.
Read the guide →

How we make these comparisons

  • Source and date on every figure. Everything we say about another tool comes from its official site, with the date we checked it written on the page.
  • No invented numbers. If a price or a feature isn't public, the cell says "not published" — which means "we have no record of it", not "it doesn't exist".
  • We say when we lose. Every comparison has a "to be fair" section explaining the cases where the other tool is the better choice.
  • Net and gross aren't comparable. Where their price excludes VAT and ours includes it, we say so: conflating the two is exactly what comparative advertising law prohibits.
  • No borrowed screenshots, no sniping. We compare verifiable features, not other people's work.
  • We keep them current. If a figure changes or you think we've got it wrong, write to hola@formulamaps.com and we'll fix it.

Frequently asked questions

Are these comparisons objective?

We don't claim to be neutral: we sell software and you're on our site. What we do guarantee is verifiability — every figure carries the site it came from and the date we read it, so you can check all of it yourself. And every page has a "to be fair" section naming the cases where the other tool is the better choice. Sales material doesn't do that.

What does FormulaMaps cost?

€69 a year, VAT included, for all five crafts — ice cream, pastry, bakery, turrón and cacao — and €49 a year in Latin America. Getting started is free: 3 formulas kept for life, and a calculator that's open with no sign-up and no card.

What if a figure is wrong?

Write to hola@formulamaps.com. That goes for the vendors we compare, too: we correct it and we date the correction. We'd rather have an accurate page than a flattering one.

The comparison that actually counts: yours

Put the same recipe in here and in the tool you're evaluating, then compare PAC, POD and total solids. Our calculator is public and asks for no sign-up — you don't have to take our word for anything.

Try the calculator free →

See our pricing — and the market's, with sources →